Much can be learned from a preventable runway overrun accident involving a commercial aircraft. By examining the contributing factors and the chain of decisions made during the incident, this scenario highlights how the same threats and decision-making challenges apply to general aviation pilots. From weather planning to tailwind limitations, the event underscores the need for consistent vigilance, sound judgment, and respect for operational limitations—no matter what aircraft is being flown.
Reflecting on Real-World Consequences
Day six of the Safer Pilot Challenge offers a sobering but important break from the cockpit. While previous sessions focused on in-air emergencies like engine failures, this segment turns attention to the dangers that still exist during landing—specifically, the risk of a runway overrun. A well-known accident involving Southwest Airlines Flight 1248 at Chicago Midway Airport provides a powerful case study in aeronautical decision-making and operational discipline.
The Flight, The Weather, and The Decision
On December 8, 2005, a Boeing 737 operating as Southwest 1248 attempted to land at Midway in challenging winter conditions. The weather had deteriorated significantly since departure, with intensifying snow and reduced visibility. While airport crews had cleared the runway prior to the aircraft’s arrival, the prevailing visibility and runway visual range (RVR) were poor—reported at only 4,500 feet, which is below ILS minimums.
With limited options, the flight crew opted to land on Runway 31 Center, which offered lower landing minimums but came with a tailwind—something that already increased risk. The tailwind was later calculated at eight knots, which exceeded Southwest’s internal maximum of five knots. Though this was not a regulatory violation, it was a direct breach of the airline’s standard operating procedures (SOPs).
Compounding Factors That Led to the Overrun
Despite the tailwind and poor braking action, calculations showed the aircraft should have been able to stop within the available runway. But that didn’t happen. The thrust reversers weren’t deployed until 18 seconds after touchdown—by that point, there was only 1,000 feet of usable runway left. The delay occurred because the captain initially struggled to get the reversers out of the stowed position. The first officer eventually intervened, but it was too late to prevent the runway excursion. The aircraft overran the pavement, breached the airport boundary, and tragically collided with a vehicle outside the airport, resulting in the death of a child.
Three Key Failures Identified by the NTSB
The NTSB cited three primary contributing factors to the accident: Inadequate assessment of runway conditions by the flight crew, failure to deploy reverse thrust promptly, and the pilot’s decision to land despite deteriorating weather and exceeding SOP limitations.
Each of these highlights a breakdown in risk management and crew resource management—both essential skills for pilots at all levels.
What General Aviation Pilots Can Learn
While general aviation pilots typically fly smaller aircraft like a Cessna 172 under Part 91, the lessons from this airline accident are still highly relevant. First, preflight planning and weather assessment must be taken seriously. Changing weather—especially in winter—requires flexibility and the willingness to divert if conditions don’t support a safe landing. Second, standard operating procedures and aircraft limitations exist for a reason. Even when flying under less stringent regulations, self-imposed personal minimums are critical. Lastly, CRM skills aren’t just for two-pilot airline crews. Even a solo private pilot must learn to recognize when something isn’t right and respond accordingly.
By reflecting on incidents like these, pilots can recommit to the highest standards of safety and professionalism. Whether training for a private pilot certificate, instrument rating, or working toward becoming a commercial pilot or flight instructor, each flight is an opportunity to improve—and every accident offers a chance to learn without repeating past mistakes.
Get the MzeroA Checkride Book Series
Ready to ace your checkride? Take preparation to the next level with the MzeroA Checkride Book Series. Packed with in-depth knowledge, real-world scenarios, and insight, these books are designed to help you walk into your checkride with confidence. Whether you’re a student or a seasoned pilot looking to brush up on your knowledge, check out the Private, Instrument and Commercial books today! Copies are available in paperback, audio and e-book.